American Idol

[Janet]

 

 

[Kelli Combs (admin)]

I liked Jesse too.  I actually thought the guy who should have won the Voice should have been Christina's last guy, the opera singer.  Can't remember his name.  He was amazing and unique and really what the Voice is all about I thought.   Guess you never know. 

If he didn't win, I liked C Lo's last girl; the rock singer.  She's pretty good too.  I love that raspy voice of hers; so cool!

[Janet]

 

I don't care who wins either.  I felt the same way about The Voice after Christina got rid of Jesse. 

[Kelli Combs (admin)]

I know Phil is going to win, hands down.  I don't get the whole Jessica thing either.  Maybe it's because she's only 16 years old or something.  You can't deny she has talent, though.  It's a no-brainer at this point who is going to win. 

Now that Joshua is gone, I don't really care.  I sure hope he goes a long way in his career.  He deserves it.  Hopefully he can find some songs to match that huge voice of his.  Good luck to you, Joshua!!

[Keith Rowan II]

Agreed with that!  Screaming comes naturally to her...haha.

[Janet]

 

I don't think performing comes naturally to Jessica.  She either stands there or looks awkward trying to move around and entertain.  Skylar was a great performer.  I'd rather see her in the final.  I don't think Jessica is going to learn how to become an entertainer in a week.

[Keith Rowan II]

Sorry, Kelli.  I know you liked Josh.  Lily and I were surprised; we both thought Jessica was going home.  She was easily the worst the other night.  Josh, even though I don't like him all that much, was probably the best.  He deserved to be in the final.  Oh well.  I like Phil so I hope he wins.  I've never liked Jessica. I just don't see what other people see in her.  I do not like her voice, style, anything about her.  Go Phil (personally, I thought he was awesome the other night, probably his best night).   I think he will win too, Kelli, but you never know.

[Kelli Combs (admin)]

I agree with you, Janet.  I think Phil is going to take it.  I didn't think he was that great on the Bob Seger song either; seemed almost a deer in headlights look on his face.  Totally bummed Josh went home. 

[Janet]

 

I was a bit surprised by the final two.  I honestly still don't get why people like Phil.  The judges went crazy over We've Got Tonight.  He did sound better than usual since he got out of that mid range, but it was nowhere near as good as Bob Seger's version.  Comparing Phil to Bruce Springstein?  I don't think so.   I hope Jessica wins, but I have a feeling it will be Phil.

[Kelli Combs (admin)]

Who is Jimmy Lovine?  The name sounds familiar but I can't quite place him.  We need more criticism; everyone is so nice and complementary all the time.  Boring!!

Oh, it just came to me.  He's the guy that gives the constructive criticism to the contestants.  I like him; he's the only honest one of the bunch and tells it how it is. 

[Janet]

 

Actually, he'd be a good choice.  He is brutally honest, like Simon was.