I have a sentence where the attorney uses "meaning" to clarify, but what comes after that is in the form of an independent clause, so I'm not sure how to punctuate.

She says:
So you don't recall those discussions meaning do you know whether any discussions took place?

I want to put a comma after "discussions," but then do I just leave the rest alone? She does pause after "meaning"; could I put a dash after it?

Thanks for your help!
Denise

Views: 35

Replies to This Discussion

How about

So you don't recall those discussions? Meaning, do you know whether any discussions took place?
This is a tough one, meaning I don't know what the answer is! I'd go with a comma, meaning that's what I'd do right now but who knows what I'll decide five minutes from now. And of course we need the comma before "but" because there's an independent clause on either side of the word "but," but in this case I'll leave it with no comma, meaning that when a sentence flows, there are times when a deviation from a rule might be okay.
I would do it this way:

So you don't recall those discussions? Meaning do you know whether any discussions took place?

question mark after discussions,
I think any of those would work. Now I just have to decide which one.

Thanks for the help.

Denise

RSS

Latest Activity

Troy Swezey commented on Kelli Combs (admin)'s group Proofreaders
yesterday
Troy Swezey commented on Janet's page Proofreaders
yesterday
Erica Field joined Kelli Combs (admin)'s group
Thursday
Kim Kyle commented on Janet's page Scopists
Thursday
Carol Lancaster is now a member of CSRNation
Wednesday
GregoryEdwards LLC joined Kelli Combs (admin)'s group
Wednesday
Newman Proofreading shared Janet's page on Facebook
Tuesday
Erica Field joined Kelli Combs (admin)'s group
Monday
Erica Field joined Kelli Combs (admin)'s group
Monday
Newman Proofreading commented on Janet's page Proofreaders
Monday
Newman Proofreading updated their profile
Monday
Newman Proofreading posted a status
"Hi! We are looking for new proofreaders to join our team!! Please email us with any questions jayproof.reader@gmail.com"
Monday

© 2025   Created by Kelli Combs (admin).   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service